The Cozy Tavern

Post image for The Cozy Tavern

by Doug on March 6, 2015

The Cozy Tavern is a brand new bar and restaurant that opened about two weeks ago on South Street across from the South Street Smokehouse and the Akropolis. They seem to have done a lot of renovation, or perhaps even full reconstruction, from whatever was in that location before. So, the interior is new and, dare I say, cozy. The place was pretty full. But when the weather warms up, they seem to have an enclosed porch type setup that will expand capacity.

It was perfect for meeting up with some of the guys on a weekday evening and shooting the breeze while the basketball game was on in the background. It was fine for watching sports, but there are better sports bars if that’s what you’re after. What the place did have that I haven’t seen before, is a self-pour beer station. If you want to use the self-pour station, they give you a gadget on a bracelet that interacts with screens at the station. To get the bracelet, you give the waiter your driver’s license, the two are synched somehow, then you get your ID back with the bracelet. There are eight taps with electronic screens above. The screens tell you which beer is at that tap (when I went, they were mostly if not entirely Indiana craft brews) and provide information about the beer – alcohol content, IBUs, price per ounce, etc. You grab a large or small glass from the rack, then activate the tap by holding your bracelet up to the bottom right hand corner. The display tells you how many ounces you’ve poured and how many ounces total you have on your account. The bracelet is good for 36 ounces — I suspect you can reload or get a new one if you want. At the end, they ring you up for what you drank. Pro-tip: the beer station has a glass washer where you turn the glass upside down, push down, and it sprays your glass from underneath.

So, it was really good beer and the delivery concept was interesting. What about the food? The reuben I had was outstanding. Good corned beef, good sauerkraut, good bread. Just delicious. The other guys spoke highly of their food – a pork burger and a bison burger. We also had some fried guacamole that was o.k., but didn’t do much for me — possibly because I’m not a huge fan of guacamole in the first place. The house made pork rinds were a little surprising in that they were served in a paper sack, but the pork rinds themselves were terrific.

Service was very friendly but took some time. We weren’t in any hurry so it wasn’t a problem. I suspect the people are still learning the systems — they have not yet had their grand opening. So, I wouldn’t take the slow service last night as representative, but if you’re in a rush, you might wait until you have a little time.

All in all, a good experience – great beer, terrific food. I’ll be back.

Kid Friendly: No.
Price: Mid-range – $12 for a sandwich, dinners $15-20.
Location: 3312 South Street, Lafayette, Indiana (map it)
: (765) 464-6916
Cuisine: Pub
The Cozy Tavern on Urbanspoon


1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

Parkside Seafood House

February 19, 2015
Thumbnail image for Parkside Seafood House

So, have you all been waiting for this one? I luckily had a chance to visit this restaurant tonight, but it’s definitely been on my radar. If you haven’t heard, it’s a new seafood place over by Columbian Park. It’s located right across from the parking lot for Tropicanoe Cove. Number one thing you should know […]

Read the full review →

Blue House Restaurant & Grill

September 10, 2014
Thumbnail image for Blue House Restaurant & Grill

You may have noticed that Lafayette Eats has been fairly silent in recent months. It’s not that I’ve given up writing reviews… more that there’s not much left for me to review! The other day, I was eating at El Chicano and noticed across the street a new place called Blue House Restaurant and Grill. […]

Read the full review →

Shellie’s Café

June 19, 2014
Thumbnail image for Shellie’s Café

My wife and I had a rare opportunity to sneak in a date the other morning, so we opted to go out to breakfast. Although we have lived in the area for over seven years, we had never tried Shellie’s Cafe. It was a mistake to have waited so long. The building looks remarkably like […]

Read the full review →


February 17, 2014
Thumbnail image for Parthenon

After eating at the Parthenon yet again, it has come to my attention that this review was really in need of a revamp. I haven’t revisited it since the Parthenon moved from Chauncey Mall, and as it’s become one of my favorite places, I figured it deserved another look. The new location is way out […]

Read the full review →

Sushi Don Asian Fusion

February 2, 2014
Thumbnail image for Sushi Don Asian Fusion

Sushi Don Asian Fusion opened in December 2013 in the former location of Maza II, at the northwest corner of US 52 and Main Street in Lafayette. Similar to Maza, Sushi Don specializes in Korean and Japanese fare. I was not aware that Maza II had closed, and when a friend asked me to have […]

Read the full review →

Ichiban Sichuan Chinese Restaurant

December 26, 2013
Thumbnail image for Ichiban Sichuan Chinese Restaurant

There have been a variety of restaurants at the corner of 4th and South streets. You had Blue Fin Bistro, then Lushan (both by same owners), and before that Lafayette City Grill. The newest restaurant to grace this presence in 2013 is Ichiban Sichuan. I got a chance to try it out the other day, […]

Read the full review →