Shellie’s Café

Post image for Shellie’s Café

by Ben Cotton on June 19, 2014

My wife and I had a rare opportunity to sneak in a date the other morning, so we opted to go out to breakfast. Although we have lived in the area for over seven years, we had never tried Shellie’s Cafe. It was a mistake to have waited so long.

The building looks remarkably like an old Wendy’s on the outside, but inside the decor is far more kitschy. It’s an American diner in the finest sense. The restaurant was clean and inviting, and the staff was welcoming. The menu featured the usual breakfast and lunch offerings of comfort food and home cookin’.

Except I never had cooking like that a home. My mom’s pancake recipe has been well-received by friends and family alike, but it has nothing on the Shellie’s pancakes. Thin-but-fluffy and with the slightest hint of a crisp on the bottom, the pancakes had the perfect taste and texture. And they are huge to boot.

In addition to the pancakes, I also got a half order of the biscuits and gravy. Those who know me are aware that I take biscuits and gravy very seriously. Until my trip to Shellie’s Cafe, I thought the best place to get your fill was the former Breakfast Factory in Indianapolis. Shellie’s biscuits are fluffy and the gravy is plentiful and has a taste to make your eyes light up with pure joy.

My wife got the Cafe omelet, a gigantic three-egg omelet stuffed with sausage, cheese and vegetables and topped with gravy. It, too, was delicious and incredibly filling. The menu has lunch items, too, but with breakfast like this, who needs lunch?

The prices were very reasonable, especially considering the taste and portion sizes. Although many of the patrons appeared to be regulars, there was no sense of “you ain’t from around here” that you sometimes get at small, local eateries. The staff was warm and attentive; I never saw the bottom of my coffee cup. Shellie’s Cafe is easily the highlight of the Teal Road corridor.

Kid friendly: Yes
Location: 1400 Teal Rd, Lafayette (map it) Phone: (765) 471-2734
Cuisine: American

You can follow Ben on Twitter at @funnelfiasco.

{ 1 comment }

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...


February 17, 2014
Thumbnail image for Parthenon

After eating at the Parthenon yet again, it has come to my attention that this review was really in need of a revamp. I haven’t revisited it since the Parthenon moved from Chauncey Mall, and as it’s become one of my favorite places, I figured it deserved another look. The new location is way out […]

Read the full review →

Sushi Don Asian Fusion

February 2, 2014
Thumbnail image for Sushi Don Asian Fusion

Sushi Don Asian Fusion opened in December 2013 in the former location of Maza II, at the northwest corner of US 52 and Main Street in Lafayette. Similar to Maza, Sushi Don specializes in Korean and Japanese fare. I was not aware that Maza II had closed, and when a friend asked me to have […]

Read the full review →

Ichiban Sichuan Chinese Restaurant

December 26, 2013
Thumbnail image for Ichiban Sichuan Chinese Restaurant

There have been a variety of restaurants at the corner of 4th and South streets. You had Blue Fin Bistro, then Lushan (both by same owners), and before that Lafayette City Grill. The newest restaurant to grace this presence in 2013 is Ichiban Sichuan. I got a chance to try it out the other day, […]

Read the full review →

Professor Joe’s

December 4, 2013
Thumbnail image for Professor Joe’s

Recently I’ve seen a lot of check-ins at a place called “Professor Joe’s” in downtown Lafayette. I hadn’t heard of it, so I went looking for more information. I found their Facebook page, which describes them as an “Upscale Sports Pub.” I found this interesting. I’m not sure how you make a sports pub upscale. […]

Read the full review →


August 28, 2013
Thumbnail image for Maza

I had an opportunity to go to Maza last night for dinner, and I’m glad I did. I get to update my review to reflect my current experience. It’s still in the old Pizza King/Sorrentos location on Sagamore Parkway, so the location for much of our area isn’t ideal, but it’s great for me since […]

Read the full review →

Lenehan’s Pub

June 6, 2013
Thumbnail image for Lenehan’s Pub

Let’s not dance around the elephant in the room. This location seems cursed. In conjunction with announcing the opening of the new Lenehan’s Pub, Hayleigh Colombo, writing for the Lafayette Journal & Courier had a story listing previous efforts recently at this location. Lenehan’s is at the location previously occupied by the Cajun Connection (2003), […]

Read the full review →